AWS needs a bug bounty program
A few weeks ago, while evaluating an AWS service, I stumbled upon an issue with the way the AWS API evaluates IAM policies for a particular IAM action. I contacted email@example.com about that and was positively surprised about the professionalism in which the team handled my request. In the end, my reported issue was classified as a won’t fix. AWS updated the documentation to clarify the behavior. Fine!
The whole process made me think about how AWS handles vulnerability reports from its customers and ethical hackers. And I realized that AWS does not offer a bug bounty program. That’s a poor choice, in my opinion.
What is a bug bounty program? The deal is simple. An individual reports a bug to an organization and receives compensation in return. Most often, those bug bounty programs focus on security exploits and vulnerabilities. The bug bounty program sets the rules for reporting a bug and receiving compensation, typically based on severity. For example, when reporting a bug that could lead to remote code execution on Azure, Microsoft will pay you up to $40,000.1
Special offer: cloudonaut t-shirt
Do you love our blog posts and podcast episodes? Unlock our weekly videos and online events by subscribing to cloudonaut plus.
Special offer: Join cloudonaut plus before November 30th, and we will send you a cloudonaut t-shirt for free.Subscribe now!
In my opinion, having a public bug bounty program is essential for two reasons:
- Filing a high-quality bug report is a lot of work. Customers who do the extra work of reporting their observations should be compensated. Otherwise, some bugs will never be reported.
- Attracting independent security experts - some call them ethical hackers - to uncover vulnerabilities provides an extra layer of protection.
I can’t find a reason for not having a bug bounty program.
Let’s compare the major cloud providers
|✅ Yes||❌ No|
|✅ Microsoft Azure1||❌ Amazon Web Services|
|✅ Google Cloud Platform2||❌ Oracle Cloud|
|✅ Alibaba Cloud3||❌ IBM Cloud4|
|✅ Tencent Cloud5|
Four of seven cloud providers offer a bug bounty program. Unfortunately, the market leader Amazon Web Services, does not. Even though AWS never misses an opportunity to assure security is their top priority. If these are not empty promises, I expect AWS to launch a bug bounty program soon!
- 1. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/msrc/bounty-microsoft-azure ↩
- 2. https://www.google.com/about/appsecurity/reward-program/ ↩
- 3. https://hackerone.com/alibaba ↩
- 4. https://hackerone.com/ibm but does not offer any bounties ↩
- 5. https://hackerone.com/tencent ↩